Revista Brasileira de Avaliação
Revista Brasileira de Avaliação
Experience report

Program evaluation of Juventud y Empleo (JE): A critical appraisal

Bernardo Menescal Ferreira da Silva

Downloads: 0
Views: 372


Like the policies they purport to assess, evaluation itself has goals and can thus also be object of appraisal. By scrutinizing an evaluation, we gain insights into its applicability to actual decision-making, which might help curb premature excitement or disappointment with the results. Foremost, however, the critical review can provide guidance for evaluators seeking to refine their strategies. This essay presents a critical assessment of the 2011 evaluation study conducted by David Card et al. on the landmark Juventud y Empleo policy in the Dominican Republic. This is done, first, via a reconstruction of the implementation stages; second, the evaluation’s implicit logic model is made explicit; and, finally, we reflect on the quantitative analyses/controls employed. We find that the study shines in modelling participant attrition and quantitatively estimating the bias in (re)assignment. At the same time, we suggest (a) that the inclusion of logic models in published evaluations can boost transparency, reproducibility and support its assessment and (b) a better overview of implementation hurdles can provide a more adequate, context-sensitive frame within which to weight the effect sizes of the intervention.


Labor policy. Policy evaluation. Critical assessment


Bevir, Mark. (2010). Encyclopedia of Political Theory. London: SAGE Publications. http://dx.doi. org/10.4135/9781412958660

Blossfeld, Hans-Peter, & Rohwer, Götz (2019). Event history analysis with Stata (2nd ed.). Routledge: Taylor & Francis Group.

Bryant, Antony. (2020). The grounded theory method. In Patricia Leavy (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of qualitative research (pp. 166-199). Oxford: Oxford University Press. oxfordhb/9780190847388.013.15

Card, David, Ibarrarán, Pablo, Regalia, Ferdinando, Rosas-Shady, David, & Soares, Yuri. (2011). The labor market impacts of youth training in the Dominican Republic. Journal of Labor Economics, 29(2), 267-300.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention – CDC. National Center for HIV/AIDS, viral hepatitis, STD and TB prevention. (2007). Types of evaluation. Retrieved 2022, March 21, from program/pupestd/Introduction.pdf

The World Bank. (2005). Población urbana (% del total) - Dominican Republic. Retrieved 2022, March 21, from

van den Berg, Gerard J., & Uhlendorff, Arne. (2015). Economic job search and decision-making models. In Ute-Christine Klehe & Edwin A. J. van Hooft (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of job loss and job search (vol. 1). New York: Oxford University Press.

Wallenborn, Manfre. (2010). Vocational education and training and human capital development: Current practice and future options. European Journal of Education, 45(2), 191-198. j.1465-3435.2010.01424.x

Submetido em:

Aceito em:

64a449f2a953951e1b525ef2 rbaval Articles
Links & Downloads

Revista Brasileira de Avaliação

Share this page
Page Sections